Talk:Musical terminology
From Academic Kids
I like this page, but I have a question about its scope; are we going to duplicate the entire list of musical topics? -- Merphant 08:48, 21 Dec 2003 (UTC)
- I see it as a list of pre-stub definitions of musical subjects. When they become enough for a stub they can be moved to the redirects.Hyacinth 08:50, 21 Dec 2003 (UTC)
I'm not happy with articles which could easily be more than stubs being redirected here (even if they are stubs at the moment). You make the reader pick through a lot of irrelevent info to get to what they want, and it also discourages expansion. I am going to restore a couple of things which have been redirected here - I don't see a problem with them being kept on this page as well, for reference (in fact, I think this page would work best a collection of brief definitions with links out to more comprehensive articles). --Camembert
- I share this unhappiness. In addition, a lot of the articles being, or potentially being, messed with talk to a lot more than music (Assonance, Dissonance, Cadence) and will sometimes need major rewriting if the music stuff is just excised. Please stop doing it for now. Bmills 15:49, 23 Dec 2003 (UTC)
Okay, stopped. In my defense, see Texture (music). Cadence has already been messed with, but not involving this article, see Cadence (music).Hyacinth 16:01, 23 Dec 2003 (UTC)
- all betterHyacinth 19:32, 23 Dec 2003 (UTC)
clef.org
I can't get the clef.org glossary (http://clef.org) extlink on the page to work; all it shows is the main page. Is it just my browser (Mozilla/OSX) or is the site broken? -- Merphant 02:53, 24 Dec 2003 (UTC)
- The lack of a www in the address seems to have an effect - try it again now. --Camembert
- Aha, that solved it. Thanks! -- Merphant 03:05, 24 Dec 2003 (UTC)
missing terms
R.H. = Right Hand L.H = Left Hand
m.s. = Don't know what it is cannot add it.
wikipedias should gather together and merge this with the italian. some time soon, so 'forte' articles can point or have a catogery to point --Nkour 14:22, 6 Jan 2005 (UTC)
MS and MD, and their expansions, now added. Portamento details added. It is hard to know how much detail should be included. --Noetica 10:00, 6 Feb 2005 (UTC)
